We're a transparent startup founded by Aviel Ginzburg and Damon Cortesi building solutions in the social media and public relations spaces.

Follow along as we share the ups and downs of building a startup.

Follow Untitled Startup on Twitter
Tweeps Who Like Us
ericpetersmattappersonfbaumdavidhoangdudeman718kevinmarkslouisgrayjoannalordmsaleemshaunacauseysh3n3rdpistachiorsarvereddavemcclurescobleizerneilpatelkegill

Disappointed by the inflexibility of recurring payment solutions.

Jan
31

Epic and informative blog post is forthcoming… but it’s been an infuriating although informative weekend.  If only we had a simple use case…

  • Danny
    Have you tried: BrainTree Payment Solutions, or Magento + the recurring extension from Aheadworks (a bit pricey) or Expression Engine + FoxyCart
  • Also check out Aria: http://ariasystems.com
  • Richard Nyström
    I have been struggling with recurring billing too for a couple of weeks but my problem is that there are no payment gateways that supports swedish companies in Spreedly, Chargify or Recurly. I didn't think that should be such a huge problem in 2010....
  • Did you guys investigate Amazon's Flexible Payments Service? I didn't see/hear it mentioned.

    http://aws.amazon.com/fps
  • We looked at the three mentioned because we were hoping for a simple solution out of the box that we could implement quickly. We started to take a look at FPS (it's in the spreadsheet linked above and met several of our requirements), but required a little more time investment than we had. Haven't ruled it out, though.
  • Recurly
    We're totally with you- subscription billing is insanely frustrating/infuriating. That's why we put Recurly together to help take out some of the drama and the pain. One quick thing to note, we do support one time transactions. We've got a docs page up that talks about this:
    http://support.recurly.com/faqs/api/transactions

    Let us know if we can help!
  • untitledstartup
    Thanks for reaching out and updating the docs last night. Unfortunately, from what we can tell, you only support the one time payments on top of pre-existing subscriptions. If you can prove us wrong, we would be infinitely grateful.

    That being said, on the recurring front, in our minds you guys definitely beat out http://chargify.com and http://spreedly.com.
  • Recurly
    You are right- we can do one time transactions for subscribers, but not non-subscribers. We updated our page more on this at:
    http://support.recurly.com/faqs/advanced/one-time-transactions

    We'd love to get your thoughts on how you'd ideally like one time payments to work. Would it be a payment occur at times after signup? Would they occur before a subscription is purchased? Please let us know, we'd love the feedback. Thanks!
  • untitledstartup
    Thanks again for reaching out and updating your documentation. You guys should take RackSpace to court over "fanatical support", I think you've got a case.

    In our minds, one of the toughest parts of monetizing a product via a subscription model is actually "selling the subscription", and sometimes your best way to pull that off may be via an "upsell". Our goal is to charge customers 1 time payments for set durations of our service prior to them actually purchasing a subscription. This might be because they aren't actually ready for a subscription or in our case most likely because their use case doesn't require one.

    That being said, our service might be unique in that some people may never desire a subscription, but we still want to be able to support their use case within a single payments provider as well as allow them to sign up for a subscription (when/if their ready) without having to go through another service.
  • Recurly
    We aim to please :) We're developers too so we know how crucial it is to get fast response when you're working on developing a service.

    This info is really helpful, we're grokking it now and will have some updates for you shortly. Let us know if there's anything else we can assist with- we're here to help!
  • Hey guys - I clicked on the Google Docs link to learn more, but I think it's only shared w/ your apps domain. I can't see it. And good decision not to use Paypal. Disaster sums it up nicely. Case in point: http://blog.apparentsoft.com/business/124/is-paypal-good-for-your-microisv-business-a-short-paypal-horror-story/
  • untitledstartup
    Do'h! Link works now.
blog comments powered by Disqus